Understanding the Constitutional Right to Remain Silent

The right to remain silent, which is familiar to most people through films and television shows, is rooted in the Fifth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution and parallel provisions in the Nevada Constitution. It is a powerful right and a privilege that must be protected and exercised properly in a timely manner. Knowing how to invoke the right to remain silent and understanding the limitations on the right are extremely important for everyone.

Key Takeaways

  • The right to remain silent comes from the Fifth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution and a parallel protection in Article 1, Section 8 of the Nevada Constitution.
  • The right to remain silent is always available, with limited exceptions, including before (or without) police Miranda warnings, if it is properly and timely exercised.
  • Silence alone generally does not provide the protection; the right must be invoked by speaking it out loud in an unambiguous manner. (U.S. Supreme Court in Berghuis v. Thompkins and Salinas v. Texas)
  • Exercising the right to remain silent does not automatically invoke the right to a lawyer (Nevada Supreme Court in Dewey v. State); a person must separately invoke the right to a lawyer.
  • Nevada’s stop-and-identify law requires a lawfully detained person to give police their name, notwithstanding the right to remain silent. (Upheld by the U.S. Supreme Court in Hiibel v. Sixth Judicial District Court of Nevada)
  • The right to remain silent does not protect against non-testimonial evidentiary tests, like a breath or blood test after a DUI arrest, and refusing the test can carry penalties under Nevada’s implied consent law.
  • A defendant’s decision to remain silent and not testify at trial cannot be used as evidence of guilt. (U.S. Supreme Court in Griffin v. California)

 

Where the Right to Remain Silent Comes From

The Fifth Amendment of the United States Constitution states in part that “No person … shall be compelled in any criminal case to be a witness against himself ….” There is a parallel provision in Article 1, Section 8 of the Nevada Constitution. These provisions are referred to as the privilege against self-incrimination and also as the right to remain silent.

The right means, among other things, that a person is not required to answer questions from police, investigators, or anyone else who makes inquiries about a criminal matter. The protection exists all the time, including when a person is initially detained. The person does not have to wait until they are read their rights or arrested to invoke the right to remain silent.

Miranda Warnings vs. the Right to Remain Silent

Under the U.S. Supreme Court’s decision in Miranda v. Arizona, specific warnings, known as Miranda warnings, are required before custodial interrogation begins, when a person is in custody and being questioned. The warnings are a procedural safeguard designed to protect a person’s rights at an early stage of investigation. They include the right to remain silent and the right to legal counsel. If police fail to give the required warnings, statements made by the person may be kept out of evidence, but the failure generally does not invalidate an arrest or result in a dismissal of the case. It’s important to note that there are exceptions to the Miranda rights rule.

While the right to remain silent is part of the Miranda warnings, it is a right that exists independently all the time, including before police are required to read the Miranda warnings and before arrest. Significantly, simply staying silent is not sufficient to invoke the right or stop police questioning.

How to Invoke the Right to Remain Silent

To invoke the right to remain silent, you must state out loud, without ambiguity, that you are choosing to remain silent. After invoking the right, you must completely refrain from talking or answering further questions. Under Berghuis v. Thompkins, the U.S. Supreme Court held that a person who makes a voluntary statement after receiving Miranda warnings, without first clearly invoking the right to remain silent, may be found to have waived it. Notably, in a law enforcement setting or criminal proceeding, it is critical to verbally state the intention to exercise the right to remain silent early and clearly and to then refrain from talking entirely.

In Nevada, even if you invoke the right to remain silent, the state stop-and-identify law, NRS 171.123, requires individuals to verbally identify themselves when they are lawfully detained on reasonable suspicion. The U.S. Supreme Court upheld the state law as not violating the Fifth Amendment in Hiibel v. Sixth Judicial District Court of Nevada. So, even if you invoke the right to remain silent, you may still be required to state your name. But you can decline to answer other questions after stating your name and verbally invoking the right to remain silent.

Invoking the right to remain silent does not automatically invoke the right to a lawyer, as stated by the Nevada Supreme Court in Dewey v. State. The request to have a lawyer present must be stated separately and should also be expressed at an early stage, such as at the same time as invoking the right to remain silent. After you invoke your rights, the police must generally stop questioning you and honor your request for a lawyer. It’s extremely important to stop talking and remain silent. 

In addition to exercising the right to remain silent and the right to legal counsel, a person confronted by police should also decline to consent to any type of search. You do not have to agree to allow a police search if they ask. Declining consent to a search is the best way to protect your rights.

When Nevada Law Requires a Person to Speak or Cooperate

As noted above, Nevada state law requires a person detained on reasonable suspicion to identify themselves, but the law does not require the person to answer any other questions. However, other laws require a driver to produce a driver’s license, vehicle registration, and proof of insurance when requested by police.

The right to remain silent also does not protect against an evidentiary breath or blood test after a DUI arrest, and refusing the test can carry penalties under Nevada’s implied consent law. Providing certain other types of non-testimonial evidence, such as fingerprints and DNA evidence, is also not protected by the right to remain silent.

What Happens at Trial If a Person Stays Silent

If a case goes to trial, the right to remain silent entitles a defendant to decline to testify at the trial. A prosecutor cannot comment on the defendant’s decision or suggest that declining to testify is evidence of guilt, as stated by the U.S. Supreme Court in Griffin v. California. Choosing not to testify cannot be considered an admission of guilt, and a jury cannot hold a defendant’s decision not to testify against them.

It’s important to be aware that whether a defendant testifies at trial is a strategic decision that is made by a defendant in consultation with their legal counsel, based on the overall case strategy.

Protecting the Right to Remain Silent

The United States Supreme Court has gone to great lengths in numerous case decisions to protect the rights guaranteed by the Fifth Amendment, including the right to remain silent. Every person has that right, with a few carefully defined limitations recognized by the courts, as discussed above. To preserve the right effectively, it must be invoked at the earliest opportunity, along with other important rights, as soon as police indicate they want to ask you questions.

Do not wait for police to give you the Miranda warnings before you invoke the right to remain silent and the right to have a lawyer present. As soon as you invoke your right to remain silent, police must generally stop questioning you.

If you are stopped, you should cooperate with law enforcement and remain polite to the extent possible without giving up any of your rights. As the Miranda warnings state, if you waive the right to remain silent by talking to police, anything you say can and will be used against you in a criminal proceeding.

Schedule a Free Consultation With an Experienced Las Vegas Criminal Defense Attorney

If you have been detained or face state or federal criminal charges in Las Vegas, Henderson, or elsewhere in Clark County, you need an aggressive criminal defense attorney who not only understands the laws and local courts and practices, but also knows how to analyze all the evidence. Criminal defense attorney Joseph Gersten will evaluate your case based on his extensive investigative background and Las Vegas criminal defense experience. Your initial consultation is always free. Call 702.857.8777 or complete our online form to schedule an appointment.