How Commingling Separate and Community Property Causes Problems in a Nevada Divorce
In a Nevada divorce, state law requires division of community property acquired during the marriage; separate property of each spouse is generally preserved and not divided. In some cases, an issue may arise when separate property was commingled with community property, which could result in the separate property becoming community property subject to division.
In a contested divorce, the court determines the issue of commingling separate and community property as part of property division. In a divorce settlement agreement negotiated between the parties, the spouses and their lawyers must navigate the question of commingling of separate and community property to arrive at a mutually agreeable property settlement agreement.
Key Takeaways
- As a community property state, Nevada recognizes two types of property in a marriage: separate property, which is owned by one spouse, and community property, which is owned by both spouses. Community property is subject to division in a divorce; separate property is not divided.
- Commingling separate and community property, even unintentionally, may result in the separate property becoming community property, subject to division in a divorce.
- To avoid legal issues relating to commingled property in a divorce, spouses should take affirmative steps to protect separate property owned before a marriage or acquired during the marriage.
Nevada Community Property Laws
Nevada is a community property state. Most property owned by married spouses is classified as either community property or separate property. NRS 123.130 generally defines separate property to include property owned by a spouse before marriage or acquired individually after marriage as a gift, inheritance, or personal injury damage award.
In a different section, NRS 123.220, the law defines community property as any property acquired after a marriage by either spouse or both spouses that does not qualify as separate property under the preceding definition, with these limited exceptions:
- The spouses have a written agreement (such as a prenuptial or postnuptial agreement) that defines specific property as separate property of one spouse;
- A decree of separate maintenance was issued by a court;
- In a written agreement, one spouse granted the other spouse authority to appropriate the first spouse’s earnings to their own use, pursuant to NRS 123.190; or
- A decree issued or agreement in writing entered pursuant to NRS 123.259 (which allows a court to divide the income and resources of a married couple when one spouse is institutionalized and the other spouse remains in the community).
When a court divides property in a divorce, NRS 125.150 provides for an “equal disposition” of the community property “to the extent practicable.” To make an unequal division, the court must find a compelling reason, such as financial misconduct, to do so and provide the reasons for unequal division in writing. Other qualifications also apply. To summarize: While property division is often 50-50 in a Nevada divorce, unequal division is possible in some circumstances.
The characterization of property as community property or separate property is the central determining factor in property division during divorce. However, in some situations, separate property and community property can be commingled (mixed together) to an extent that the separate property is not clearly identifiable. When that happens, separate property may become community property for purposes of division.
How Commingling Separate and Community Property Occurs
Commingling separate and community property can create legal complications during a divorce. When separate and community property are intermixed so that the separate portions cannot be clearly identified or traced, commingling of assets occurs, and the entire asset is presumed to be community property, subject to division under Nevada law.
Examples of how commingling occurs include:
- Depositing separate property (such as premarital funds) into a shared bank account where other shared funds of the spouses (like paychecks) are also deposited.
- A business started and separately owned before the marriage in which the spouses invest community funds or both spouses contribute time and energy to running the business.
- Purchasing jointly-owned real estate using separate funds of one spouse for the down payment, and using community income to pay for expenses, including the mortgage and repairs or renovations.
Nevada law presumes that any property acquired during a marriage is community property. If a spouse claims that specific property is separate property after it has been commingled with community property, the burden of proof is on the claimant spouse to prove by clear and convincing evidence that the separate property remained separate. The proof can be provided through detailed financial records, bank statements, and other accounting documentation that trace and identify the original separate funds.
In the absence of proof, commingled separate property may be determined by a court to be community property subject to division. The same issue arises (and must be resolved) in a negotiated property settlement if the spouses and their lawyers cannot agree on whether specific assets are separate or community property.
How to Avoid Issues of Commingling Separate and Community Property
The best time to identify which property should remain separate in the event of divorce is usually before a marriage takes place. For separate property acquired during the marriage (such as an inheritance or personal injury award), the issue should be addressed soon after the property is acquired. The best protection for separate property is a valid written agreement, such as a prenuptial or postnuptial agreement, which serves to define and protect separate property and keep it distinct from community property.
Maintaining separate property in completely distinct accounts that are not mixed with joint funds is a critical step. Dedicated accounts for premarital assets and inheritances or personal injury settlements are essential. In addition, documentation such as detailed financial statements, deeds, and transaction records should be retained indefinitely.
In addition to a written agreement, abiding by strict rules for handling separate property can prevent commingling separate and community property in divorce. Such rules include:
- Do not combine separate property and community property for any reason, in any account.
- Do not use separate property to purchase, maintain, or improve community property.
- Do not use community property to maintain or improve separate property.
- Keep separate property and community property accounts completely separated, and do not transfer funds between the two types of accounts.
These rules may seem redundant, which illustrates how important it is to avoid every conceivable way of commingling separate property and community property. In addition, documenting all financial transactions to demonstrate compliance with these rules is another logical step to ensuring protection of separate property.
Free Consultation With an Experienced Las Vegas Divorce Attorney
Respected family law attorney Joseph Gersten assists clients with property settlement and asset division issues and all other concerns that arise in Clark County divorce cases. At The Gersten Law Firm, your initial consultation is always free-of-charge. We work with clients in Las Vegas, Henderson, and throughout Clark County with all types of family and domestic matters. Call 702.857.8777 or complete our online form to schedule an appointment.